A reader asks: Should I jump??

Written by Alex

Topics: Investing

Nooo!

Ok… so we aren’t talking about bridges or anything, despite this crazy picture…

We are talking about “jumping” savings accounts to take advantage of better rates. Granted, high savings accounts rates these days are slim pickin’s, but you can tell from the font size of %-rates in newspapers how much banks want to win your money. Does it make sense to switch?

It depends on the rate difference. Here’s my current situation:

I have an ING Savings account – APY 3.00%. HSBC is currently offering 3.50%. Should I open an HSBC account and move my savings there? When you are talking about a measly 3%, 0.5% sounds like a lot. Let’s do some quick math…

First, let’s check the rate we are using. Banks vary their compounding method (daily, monthly, etc) which means APR’s are not all created equal. Luckily for unwitting consumers, if you look at APY this is your rate considering compounding. So it’s apples to apples. Plus you can use it to easily calculate how much interest you’ll earn if you invest your moo-la for a whole year:

[your money now] x (1+APY) = [your money later]

Say I have $5000 saved in ING. At the end of the year, I’ll have 5000 x 1.03 = $5150.
If I put that in HSBC, I’d have $5175…. $25 difference! And if I’m in the 28% tax bracket, it’s really $18.

Is it worth jumping? I’ll let you be the judge – for me, the simplicity of a small number of accounts (with statements) and time savings of not tracking rates all the time is well worth that small loss.

3 Comments Comments For This Post I'd Love to Hear Yours!

  1. Fred Bartle says:

    Good info Alex, I had considered the same thing myself, thinking that 3.50% looked pretty tasty. Like you, I’m trying to keep things simple as I’m already overwhelmed with trying to manage my money. Thanks!

    -Fred

  2. Evan says:

    Alex,
    I also don’t have the energy for jumping unless its really worth it, what is your experience on the banks that routinely give interest rates in the upper decile. We have traditionally used USAA and ING.

    EJ

    Idea for future post: the best strategies for college savings for your children

  3. Alex says:

    EJ, the best rates I’ve seen are at ING, HSBC (although watch out for teaser rates) and a credit union near where I grew up in NJ called Affinity Credit Union. I definitely prefer ING simply because I have checking there as well. USAA doesn’t seem competitive to me for savings rates though… and I prefer to avoid minimum balances wherever possible – flexibility is key.

    Thanks for the post idea – I definitely will cover college savings soon!

    -Alex

Leave a Comment Here's Your Chance to Be Heard!